| Hindsight Is 2020 |

This Isn’t the MUSIC of 2010

We’re closing a decade and Jewish music has stretched, expanded, blurred


or as long as I can remember, the mainstream producers of frum Jewish music followed a clear formula: find a pasuk, usually from davening or Tehillim, and compose a tune with a “low part” and “high part” to fit the words. Or, if you’re creative, find a Torah-themed message — something about the power of Shabbos or getting ready for Mashiach — and compose a nice ballad to match. Along with the low part and high part, you could add a bridge too.

We’re closing a decade and Jewish music has stretched, expanded, blurred. Sweet little cheder boys are warbling what you might call “Israeli taxi driver music” and campers are clapping and bopping to kosher riffs on department store tunes. Pesukim are optional. Hebrew words are usually a plus. (Modern Hebrew, obviously, not Lashon Hakodesh.)

The latter genre includes lots of sunny skies and new days. It’s light, it’s fun, it usually sticks to major keys and steers clear of drama. It’s not “Od Yishama” or “Avraham Yagel” or even “Lo Yisa Goy.” It’s breezy and slick and more universal, more open. A good match for a generation that likes smooth facades, instant gratification, and happy endings (and beginnings and middles).

But it’s the first kind — the taxi driver music — that fascinates me, not just because of what it says about music but because of what it says about all of us. These songs will often have Middle Eastern touches — an oud or dulcimer in the background, a maqam-influenced trill — but I don’t think those nods to Mizrahi sound are really so earth-shattering. Something much more consequential is happening. After a few decades of increasing slickness to the point where our music has become slippery smooth in its predictability, its glib perfection, this feels different.

This music quivers with unabashed spirituality, but it’s a spirituality not necessarily connected to pesukim or learning or being yeshivish. It has a certain gravel and grit to it — in the voice, in the lyrics, in the vulnerability. It reminds us of taxi driver culture because it carries the vibe of those people who are believers even if they don’t quite keep everything: the people who talk to Hashem in a traffic jam and pull themselves out of bed when it’s still dark every single morning for a full month of Selichos, but can’t be bothered to check a hechsher.

This music taps that dynamic. It sings: I am a seeker, I crave connection, I beseech my Maker and let him into the crevices of my soul — even though my world, my life, my decisions and my day-to-day behavior are a lot looser than His laws.

So our sheltered cheder kids with their European roots and mehadrin hechsherim are singing the music of people whose food they’d never eat, whose families they’d never be meshadech with. And the heimish among our singers are all scrambling to find their own versions of this gritty, vulnerable, raw music. They realize it’s tapping something and touching something that speaks across boundaries; it’s giving voice to a genuine yearning just beneath the perfect façade of the 2020 generation — and they want to be part of it too.

Hindsight is 2020

This Isn’t the CHINUCH of 2010

We’re Not the KLAL YISRAEL of 2010

This Isn’t the COMMUNICATION of 2010

This Isn’t the HOUSING of 2010

This Isn’t the THERAPY GENERATION of 2010

(Originally featured in Mishpacha, Issue 790)


Oops! We could not locate your form.

Tagged: Hindsight is 2020