fbpx
| Magazine Feature |

A Plague on Their House?    

  Some people call it the “Kennedy Curse.” But does that mean a series of coincidental tragedies over the decades, or an other-worldly campaign targeting the progeny of one of the most powerful men of the last century?

 

A family with a long and influential history in American politics, the very name “Kennedy” conjures up images of wealth, power and presidency — at least one Kennedy family member served in federal elective office in every year from 1947 to 2011. But early on, tragedy began to strike, and it wasn’t long before the Kennedy name also became synonymous with calamity and misfortune. Disaster varied from murder to plane crashes, drownings to skiing accidents, and catastrophic illness. While there are still several prominent members of the Kennedy family in the public eye today, luck and good fortune seem to have disappeared from their lives long ago, replaced by tragedy affecting immediate family members, spouses, and even the families of spouses and friends.

For decades, there’s been much speculation about what’s come to be known as the “Kennedy Curse.” Is it all coincidence, or is there really something “bigger” that has haunted the family and taken its vengeance on the children and descendants of businessman Joseph P. Kennedy Sr.?

***

“What do you want me to do, crack up an airplane?” Senator Ted Kennedy asks with a grin.

“Nope, just parachute out of it into the convention,” his travel coordinator, Ed Moss responds.

It’s 1964, and 32-year-old Kennedy is campaigning for reelection to the Senate for Massachusetts. The state’s democratic convention is scheduled for that night, and as they head to catch their flight of out Washington, Kennedy and his aide wittily debate pulling off a spectacular entrance.

Notwithstanding a warning of bad weather and rolling fog, Moss engages pilot Ed Zimny to fly a chartered Aero Commander 680 twin-engine aircraft to Barnes Airport in Westfield. Senator Birch Bayh and his wife are soon seated in the aircraft along with Kennedy, as Bayh is the convention’s keynote speaker. The aircraft soars skyward soon after 8:00 p.m. After three hours of uneventful flying, Zimny radios the Barnes control tower that he’ll attempt an instrument landing in the zero-visibility conditions.

In the course of managing the campaigning in western states for his brother John’s 1960 Presidential run, Ted Kennedy had learned to fly. Now, as he sits in the Aero Commander, his gaze is fastened on the instrument panel. He watches intently as the altimeter sinks from 1,100 to 600 feet. To his horror, there is no glide which transforms into a bumpy but safe landing. Heart-stopping skidding along the treetops ensues instead. Then comes the bone-shaking impact. They have collided with a tree.

Bayh is brought back to consciousness by his wife’s screams. His dazed gaze flits over his startling surroundings. Cracked branches tangle with airplane wreckage. Leaves mingle with gore. The plane lies crumpled in an apple orchard, its belly slit open as though a knife has sliced through it. Zimny and Moss are clearly dead. His eyes rest on Kennedy. Bayh realizes that he’s trapped. With a burst of adrenaline, he lugs Kennedy, who is no lightweight, under his arm and out of the shambles.

Kennedy is soon sprawled on a Northampton Cooley Dickinson Hospital bed, undergoing an urgent blood transfusion. He has three crushed vertebrae, a punctured lung, broken ribs, and a profusion of internal bleeding. When the worst is over, he faces the discomfiting news — he must brace himself for a five-month recovery within the rigid confines of a Stryker frame bed.

When the news hits the press, Reporter Jimmy Breslin interviews Robert, Ted’s older brother.

“Is it ever going to end for you people?”

Bobby gives the reporter a serious answer, “If my mother hadn’t had any more children after her first four, she would have nothing now… I guess the only reason we’ve survived is that… there are more of us than there is trouble.”

“It’s a curse,” Ted’s wife Joan tells her sister-in-law Jackie Kennedy, the fresh widow of JFK, who was assassinated the year before. “Look at the things that have happened. Can we just chalk it up to coincidence?”

Later, Robert, accompanied by federal investigator and family friend Walter Sheridan, visits Ted in the hospital. “Somebody up there doesn’t like us,” Robert tells him.

 

 

Excerpted from Mishpacha Magazine. To view full version, SUBSCRIBE FOR FREE or LOG IN.

Oops! We could not locate your form.

Leave a Reply

Comments (1)


  1. Avatar
    0
    Daniel Jacobson

    I enjoy Yehuda Geberer’s and Dovi Safier’s For the Record column and it is one of the first items I flip to each week. I was particularly interested in Yehuda Geberer’s “The Rabbi, The Ambassador & The Mythical Curse” insert in the “A Plague On Their House?” article, since Rabbi Yisroel Jacobson was my great-uncle. Although I had heard the story of Rabbi Jacobson cursing Joseph Kennedy before, Yehuda’s insert prompted me to do my own research.
    Yehuda dismissed the Rabbi Jacobson story because in 1937 (when the story allegedly took place) Rabbi Jacobson was not fleeing the Nazis, Joseph Kennedy was not yet ambassador to the UK, and Rosh Hashanah did not occur during the voyage. While all this is true of the 1937 trip, as it happened there was another trip.
    On September 11, 1939 — just days after Germany invaded Poland — the S.S. George Washington set sail from Le Havre, France with virtually every available section of the ship converted into sleeping quarters to make room for US citizens fleeing Europe. The ship docked in New York harbor on September 18, the 5th of Tishrei. Rabbi Jacobson was one of the 1,746 passengers escaping the Nazis and was on board during Rosh Hashanah. And so were the Kennedys!
    Joseph’s wife Rose and children Kathleen “Kick,” Eunice, and Robert are listed on the ship manifest and reported in the newspapers as being on the ship. Although Joseph stayed behind in London, might I suggest a slight variation to the story: Perhaps it was Rose who objected to the davening and the curse was directed at her and her progeny.