The pirsumei nissa of Chanukah however is different from that of both Arba Kosos and mikra Megillah. Chazal did not require any public lighting of the menorah and the minhag of lighting it in shul is of later post-Chazal origin.[i] Yet it must be lit where it can be seen by all passersby. It contains elements of both the public and the private since it is performed by individuals but is directed toward the public. In ancient times every householder lit his menorah outside the door to his home where it would be seen by all.[ii] Yet it is also preferable for every member of the household to light his own menorah and keep it in a distinct place.[iii] While the mitzvah was performed in a public area it was done by individuals acting independently. Why does Chanukah require a unique form of pirsumei nissa combining individual performance with public display?