Join The Conversation With Mishpacha's Weekly Newsletter



Kitniyos Clash

Rabbi Nachum HaLevi and Rabbi Moshe Isaac Blau

One of the most famous rabbinical decrees is the prohibition of consuming kitniyos on Pesach. Although the prohibition itself is relatively unchallenged among Ashkenazim and the North African communities that accepted it, some aspects of it have become subjects of stormy controversies. One particularly bitter dispute regarding the use of sesame oil took place in Eretz Yisrael nearly a century ago, pitting some of the great Torah leaders of the time against each other.

Wednesday, April 13, 2011

By Torah law, only the five species of grain (wheat, barley, oats, spelt, and rye) can become chometz, and they are also the only species of grain with which one can produce matzoh that one can eat to fulfill the obligation on the Seder night.[i]

The Rambam[ii] writes explicitly, “But kitniyos, such as rice, millet, and the like, do not become chometz. Even if a person kneads rice flour with boiling water and covers it with cloth until it rises like leavened dough, it is still permitted for consumption, because this is not leavening, but spoiling.”

The Gemara[iii] does quote a minority opinion of Rabbi Yochanan ben Nuri who maintains that rice is also considered a grain, but his opinion is not accepted as halachah — as the Gemara concludes,[iv] “No one is concerned by the opinion of Rabbi Yochanan.”

The earliest source for the prohibition of kitniyos on Pesach is found in Rabbeinu Peretz’s emendations on the Smak[v]: “With regard to kitniyos ... and the like, our teachers observe a prohibition against consuming them on Pesach, and that seems to be correct … My teacher, Rabbeinu Yechiel, used to eat white beans on Pesach … He would prove [that they are permissible] from the fact that even with regard to rice, which Rabbi Yochanan ben Nuri considers a species of grain with regard to chometz, the Gemara states that no one is concerned by Rabbi Yochanan’s opinion. However, it is very difficult to permit something which the practice has been to prohibit since the days of the early sages.”

Rabbeinu Peretz concludes that we should uphold the custom prohibiting all kitniyos, not because they are actually chometz, but as a gezeirah (rabbinic injunction), for the following reasons: (a) since kitniyos is a cooked food and grain is also a cooked food, if we were to permit kitniyos, people might become confused and permit grain foods as well; (b) there are places where people make bread from kitniyos, and unlearned people might become confused and make bread from one of the five species of grain.”

Many of the Rishonim who lived shortly after Rabbeinu Peretz quote the prohibition of kitniyos and attribute it to him.[vi]

Although some initially opposed the stringency, it has become an accepted part of Pesach observance among Ashkenazim, who will not eat many types of legumes, such as rice, millet, broad beans, lentils, beans, soy, peas, and chickpeas. It is generally accepted that the definition of kitniyos with respect to this prohibition is not the same as the botanical definition of legumes. Rice and corn, for instance, are botanically defined as grains, and are nevertheless prohibited as kitniyos. On the other hand, some species botanically classified as legumes are not subject to this prohibition.

In addition to the reasons cited by Rabbeinu Peretz, poskim have advanced the following explanations for the prohibition:

1)                  Kernels of actual grain might have become mixed in with the kitniyos.[vii]

2)                  Kitniyos do become leavened and are called chometz (such as chimtzi, chumus).[viii]

3)                  It is not appropriate to consume kitniyos on Yom Tov since the Torah requires us to rejoice (Devarim 16), and the consumption of a cooked dish of kitniyos does not engender joy.[ix]

4)                  There is a type of deformed wheat that resembles grains of kitniyos.[x]

5)                  Some attribute the prohibition to a stringency that was adopted to promote perishus.[xi]

Based on the reasons for the prohibition, we can understand why the definition of kitniyos is based not on its botanical definition, but rather on the degree to which it corresponds to the various concerns behind the prohibition. [xii]

The poskim mention the following species, among others, as being subject to the prohibition of kitniyos: rice, millet, broad beans, lentils, beans, soy, peas, and chickpeas. Sesame seeds are also included in the prohibition,[xiii] since they are also considered kitniyos.[xiv]

 

To read the rest of this story, please buy this issue of Mishpacha or sign up for a weekly subscription.

Share this page with a friend. Fill in the information below, and we'll email your friend a link to this page on your behalf.

Your name
Your email address
You friend's name
Your friend's email address
Please type the characters you see in the image into the box provided.
CAPTCHA
Message


MM217
 
Evolution vs. Revolution
Shoshana Friedman I call it the “what happened to my magazine?” response
Up, Up, and Away
Rabbi Moshe Grylak What a fraught subject Eretz Yisrael is, to this day
Where Do You Come From?
Yonoson Rosenblum Could they be IDF officers with no Jewish knowledge?
Heaven Help Us
Eytan Kobre Writing about anti-Semitism should rouse, not soothe
Work/Life Solutions with Chedva Kleinhandler
Moe Mernick “Failures are our compass to success”
An Un-Scientific Survey
Rabbi Emanuel Feldman Are Jerusalemites unfriendly? Not necessarily
Out of Anger
Jacob L. Freedman How Angry Lawyer was finally able to calm down
5 Things You Didn’t Know about…Yitzy Bald
Riki Goldstein He composed his first melody at eight years old
When the Floodgates of Song Open, You’re Never Too Old
Riki Goldstein Chazzan Pinchas Wolf was unknown until three years ago
Who Helped Advance These Popular Entertainers?
Riki Goldstein Unsung deeds that boosted performers into the limelight
Your Task? Ask
Faigy Peritzman A tangible legacy I want to pass on to my children
Are You There?
Sarah Chana Radcliffe Emotional withdrawal makes others feel lonely, abandoned
A Peace of a Whole
Rebbetzin Debbie Greenblatt Love shalom more than you love being right
Seminary Applications
Rabbi Zecharya Greenwald, as told to Ariella Schiller It’s just as hard for seminaries to reject you