Join The Conversation With Mishpacha's Weekly Newsletter

The Explainer: A Deadline for DACA looms

Omri Nahmias

Will Congress stump up for Trump’s border wall to protect the Dreamers?

Wednesday, January 31, 2018

 Mishpacha image


P resident Trump said last week that he would consider offering citizenship to the so-called “dreamers,” a select group of children of illegal immigrants, over a 10- to 12-year period. Who are these dreamers, and what is the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program that protects them?

What is DACA?

President Obama created the program by executive order in 2012, but the outlines were already in place in a bill called the Dream Act, first introduced in 2001, that repeatedly failed to pass Congress. DACA is an immigration program that allows certain children who entered the United States illegally to receive protection against deportation as well as temporary work permits. DACA recipients must renew their status every two years.

The majority of immigrants to whom DACA applies originate from Mexico. The program grants the dreamers legal status, but does not provide a path to citizenship. In September, President Trump announced his intention to end the program, telling Congress that it must come up with an immigration fix and declaring that Obama’s use of an executive order to protect the immigrants was unconstitutional.

Why is the issue in the headlines now?

The Trump administration gave Congress six months to produce new immigration legislation, a deadline that ends on March 5. The recent legislative battle that resulted in a three-day government shutdown was largely over how to deal with these DACA cases.

How many children are we talking about?

About 800,000. In order to be eligible to receive legal status, the applicant must be between 15 and 36 and must have entered the United States before the age of 16. The applicant must have a clean criminal record; must be enrolled in, or have graduated from, high school, college, or the US military or Coast Guard; and must have been in the United States since 2007 without leaving the country.

What are the pros and the cons?

According to proponents, DACA has increased participation in the workforce by immigrant families, raised wages, and reduced poverty. These advocates also claim that DACA recipients have not taken jobs from American citizens. According to, there is no evidence that immigrants in the DACA category are more prone to crime than the average American.

Opponents claim that DACA protects illegal immigrants who indeed take jobs away from American citizens. Critics say the program rewards those who have broken the law, and that it will further encourage illegal immigration. When on the campaign trail, Trump promised to repeal DACA on his “first day in office.”

What did the Trump administration offer Congress?

According to the proposal, drafted by White House Chief of Staff John Kelly and senior advisor Stephen Miller, immigrants who were illegally brought into the country as children will receive legal status, and will receive a pathway to citizenship within ten to 12 years, provided they don’t tangle with the law. Under a new formula created by the White House, this new category could include up to 1.8 million immigrants.

In exchange, the president wants Congress to lay out $25 billion for the construction of a wall along the Mexican border, as well as new laws that would expedite the deportation of illegal immigrants. In addition, President Trump is proposing a change to the US immigration system whereby only spouses and children of immigrants would be offered sponsorship into the country and not extended family members (family unification). Trump also wants to end the diversity visa lottery, a program that awards green cards for up to 50,000 people annually.

What were the reactions to the White House proposal?

The Democrats claim it’s a hostile anti-immigrant program, and that they would never sanction the expulsion of the parents of child immigrants in order to anchor the legal status of those very same children.

Moderate Republicans, like Lindsay Graham and Jeff Flake, are still trying to hammer out an alternative in the form of a bipartisan compromise focusing only on those eligible for DACA and without the aggressive provisions against all the other illegals. Lawmakers hope such a plan would pass both houses of Congress and land on the president’s desk for his signature.

Trump’s electoral base is even less enthusiastic. A Breitbart News headline expressed outrage with a derisive reference to the president: “Amnesty Don Suggests Citizenship for Illegal Aliens.”

Why, then, is Trump taking this approach?

Trump wants to throw the ball into the court of the Democrats, who have been close to reaching a deal more than once. As March 5 nears, the Democrats will be increasingly anxious to legalize the status of the dreamers.

What will happen if the expiration date passes without an agreement?

Those eligible for DACA will lose their legal status, putting them at risk of expulsion from the country. Even if it’s unrealistic to arrest and expel 800,000 people, DACA recipients will nevertheless lose all their rights, including work permits and other benefits. (Originally featured in Mishpacha, Issue 696)

Related Stories

Rose Report: Poland Detached from Its Past

Binyamin Rose

Proposed Holocaust law punishes discussions of Polish guilt

Metro&Beyond: Terror in the Sunshine State?

Jacob Kornbluh

“I don’t know that I’ve ever heard anything as offensive as what we just heard”

The Opinionator: Does Israel Have a Moral Responsibility to Accept Asylum Seekers?

Gedalia Guttentag

“The left are fake humanitarians; they’re not doing this to help the migrants, they’re doing this to...

Share this page with a friend. Fill in the information below, and we'll email your friend a link to this page on your behalf.

Your name
Your email address
You friend's name
Your friend's email address
Please type the characters you see in the image into the box provided.

At Our Doorstep
Rabbi Moshe Grylak In Israel, intermarriage still has some shock value
The Wrong Conversation
Yonoson Rosenblum How can we reattach Jews to the Jewish story?
Heart on Your Sleeve
Eytan Kobre Being pro-phylactery can be downright prophylactic
The Silver Lining
Alexandra Fleksher Who is brave enough to buck the dangerous trends?
Top 5 Uniquely Jewish Words
Rabbi Dovid Bashevkin For some concepts, Yidden have the best words
10 Questions for Avi Kehat
Rachel Bachrach The Chesed Fund, for desperate people who need a fortune
On Speaking Terms
Rabbi Ron Yitzchok Eisenman He learned firsthand, “What goes around comes around”
Stressed Out
Jacob L. Freedman “We’re going to aggressively help you take care of you”
Mona Knew to Pick a Winner
Riki Goldstein “Shloime, let’s sing this on Motzaei Shabbos”
Four Stanzas You Don’t Just Sing
Riki Goldstein “This is not a niggun that you just sing!” he exclaimed
A Part of Me
Riki Goldstein The fruit of two years’ preparation and collaboration
Worth the Hassle?
Riki Goldstein Travel can be challenging for musicians and bands
Know It All
Faigy Peritzman The wiser I get, the more I realize how little I know
No Time to Breathe
Sarah Chana Radcliffe When we don’t have a minute to spare is when we pause
On Dry Ground
Rebbetzin Shira Smiles Every day we thank Hashem for the miracle of dry land